Key takeaways
- Compare five electric turkey fryers for safer indoor frying, including a 20 lb Butterball XL, a rotisserie model and an oil-free roaster for holidays.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Fried turkey is the fastest route to crisp skin and juicy meat, but the classic propane rig comes with an open flame and a long list of fire department warnings. An electric turkey fryer moves the job to a countertop or patio outlet: a thermostat holds the oil at temperature, there is no burner to blow out, and most models are certified for indoor use. You still get oil-frying speed, roughly three and a half to four minutes per pound, without standing over a jet of flame in the driveway.
This guide compares five electric options. Four are true oil fryers, led by two 10-liter Masterbuilt models that take a bird up to 20 pounds, plus a smaller 8-liter version and a Cuisinart rotisserie fryer. The fifth is an oil-free electric roaster, included because many shoppers actually want the fried-turkey result without buying or storing gallons of oil. Each pick lists its capacity limits, how it drains, and where it falls short.
How to Choose an Electric Turkey Fryer
Start with the bird, not the box. The headline turkey weight is a maximum, not a recommendation. Masterbuilt rates its 10-liter fryers for a 20 lb turkey but suggests 16 to 18 lb, and its oil-free roaster does best with a 10 to 12 lb bird despite an 18 lb ceiling. A turkey that fills the pot displaces oil toward the rim and cooks unevenly, so size the fryer one step above the bird you usually buy.
Understand the indoor claim. Electric fryers remove the open flame, which is the single biggest cause of turkey fryer fires, and the Butterball line is certified for indoor countertop use. That does not make the process risk free. You are still lowering a bird into oil at 375°F, steam and splatter are real, and a thawed, patted-dry turkey is non-negotiable. Note that one pick here, the oil-free roaster, is electric yet rated for outdoor use only.
Count the oil honestly. A 10-liter fryer needs close to 2.75 gallons of oil to reach its max fill line, and even the compact 8-liter model wants about 2 gallons. Peanut oil is the traditional choice, and that volume is a real part of the meal’s cost. The Cuisinart rotisserie design sidesteps much of this by rotating the bird through a shallow pool of oil in a 5-liter container.
Plan for draining before you buy. Nearly three gallons of used oil has to go somewhere. A built-in drain valve with a spout, as on the Masterbuilt models, lets you empty the cooled pot without lifting and tipping it, but the valve and spout need scrubbing or residue builds up and the valve starts to weep. The Cuisinart uses a drain hose into its removable oil container. Oil must cool completely first, and filtering it through cheesecloth lets you reuse it a few times.
Do not trust the dial alone. Thermostat dials on countertop fryers can drift, and the minutes-per-pound formula is a planning tool, not a doneness test. The only reliable finish line is 165°F in the deepest part of the breast, checked with a separate instant-read thermometer; ignore the pop-up indicator that comes with the turkey. Also budget preheat time: a 10-liter pot of oil can take up to 45 minutes to reach frying temperature.
Check the cord and the circuit. These are 1,650 to 1,800 watt appliances, so they want a circuit free of other big appliances. The magnetic breakaway cords on the Masterbuilt models are a genuine safety feature if the cord gets pulled, but they are short, which limits placement. Avoid extension cords unless heavy duty and rated for the wattage.
The 5 Best Electric Turkey Fryers
Masterbuilt 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer (MB20012420)
The current-generation Masterbuilt XL is the most complete package here. The stainless steel pot holds 10 liters, fries a turkey up to 20 lb, and doubles as a boiler and steamer for crawfish and vegetables the rest of the year. The basket has a lifting hook and drain clips, so the bird can drip above the oil before you move it, and the hinged lid removes for washing.
Specs
- Max turkey: 20 lb (16 to 18 lb recommended)
- Oil capacity: 10 liters, about 2.75 gallons to the max fill line
- Power: 1,650 watts
- Functions: fry, boil, steam
- Drainage: built-in drain valve with spout attachment
- Cord: magnetic breakaway power cord
- Cleanup: dishwasher-safe basket and pot components
Pros:
– Largest practical turkey capacity in a countertop electric unit
– Drain valve makes handling nearly three gallons of oil manageable
– Breakaway cord and thermostat control address the main safety worries
– Useful year-round as a boiler and steamer
Cons:
– Oil can take up to 45 minutes to preheat
– Big footprint, and heavy to store
Who it suits: Holiday hosts who fry a large turkey once or twice a year and will use the pot for seafood boils in between.
Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer XL (23011114)
The Butterball XL is the model that made indoor turkey frying mainstream, and it remains a strong pick. Its porcelain-coated inner pot sits inside a stainless shell, and the design uses up to a third less oil than a conventional propane fryer pot. It fries, boils and steams and handles a turkey up to 20 lb.
Specs
- Max turkey: 20 lb
- Oil capacity: 10 liters; uses up to 33 percent less oil than conventional fryers
- Power: 1,650 watts
- Inner pot: porcelain-coated, removable
- Functions: fry, boil, steam
- Drainage: built-in drain valve
- Weight: about 26 lb
Pros:
– Long track record and widely available replacement parts
– Porcelain-coated pot resists staining and wipes clean easily
– Same generous 20 lb capacity as the newer model
Cons:
– Older design lacks the polished finish and some refinements of the MB20012420
– Preheat is slow, as with all 10-liter electric fryers
Who it suits: Buyers who prefer a proven, widely owned model and want the porcelain pot for easier cleanup.
Cuisinart Extra-Large Rotisserie Fryer (CDF-500)
The Cuisinart takes a different approach: instead of submerging the turkey in a pot, it rotates the bird on a rotisserie through a shallow reservoir of oil. A 14 lb turkey fries in about an hour, browning evenly, and the removable oil container holds just 5 liters, a fraction of what the big pots need.
Specs
- Max turkey: 14 lb on the rotisserie
- Oil capacity: 5-liter removable container
- Power: 1,800-watt immersion heating element
- Temperature range: 175°F to 375°F
- Timer: 120 minutes
- Drainage: built-in drain hose into the removable container
- Extras: breakaway cord, vented stainless steel lid, steaming function
Pros:
– Uses far less oil than pot-style fryers, cutting cost and cleanup
– Rotisserie rotation gives even browning without turning the bird
– Strong 1,800-watt element recovers temperature quickly
Cons:
– The 14 lb turkey ceiling is too small for many holiday birds
– Rotisserie assembly and the spit mechanism add cleaning steps
– Large footprint for its capacity, at over 20 inches wide
Who it suits: Smaller households frying birds of 14 lb or less who want one appliance that deep fries weekly and handles the holiday turkey too.
Masterbuilt Butterball Oil-Free Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster (20100809)
This is the honest outlier in the guide: it uses no oil at all. A 1,650-watt element and double-wall construction cook with radiant heat, closer to roasting than frying, at about 10 minutes per pound. In exchange, you skip buying, storing and disposing of oil entirely, and a wood chip box adds smoke flavor an oil fryer cannot.
Specs
- Max turkey: 18 lb (manual recommends 10 to 12 lb for best results)
- Oil capacity: none, radiant heat cooking
- Power: 1,650 watts
- Cook time: about 10 minutes per pound
- Extras: wood chip box, tempered glass lid, removable drip pan, meat thermometer included
- Use: outdoor use only
- Warranty: 90 days
Pros:
– No oil to buy, strain, store or dispose of
– Wood chips add genuine smoke flavor
– Far less mess, with no hot oil to manage
– Works for chickens, roasts and other large cuts, not just turkey
Cons:
– It roasts rather than fries; the skin is crisp but not the shattering crust of an oil fry
– Outdoor use only, despite being electric, and the 90-day warranty is short
Who it suits: Cooks who want fried-turkey flavor without handling gallons of oil, and anyone uneasy about hot oil around kids or pets.
Masterbuilt 8 Liter 3-in-1 Electric Fryer (MB20010118)
The 8-liter Masterbuilt shrinks the 3-in-1 formula for smaller kitchens and smaller birds. It fries a turkey up to 14 lb, boils and steams, and keeps the key features of its bigger siblings: a drain valve in the inner pot, drain clips on the basket, a lifting hook and a magnetic breakaway cord. It needs about 2 gallons of oil at the max fill line.
Specs
- Max turkey: 14 lb
- Oil capacity: 8 liters, about 2 gallons to the max fill line
- Functions: fry, boil, steam
- Drainage: built-in drain valve
- Cord: magnetic breakaway power cord
- Lid: removable hinged lid
- Weight: about 15.5 lb
Pros:
– Same safety and drainage features as the XL in a smaller body
– Easier to store and light enough to move without help
– Uses less oil per cook than the 10-liter models
Cons:
– A 14 lb ceiling rules out the large birds many families buy
– Less oil means a bigger temperature dip when food goes in
– Fewer of them in circulation, so accessories and parts are scarcer
Who it suits: Couples and small families who fry a modest turkey and want the Masterbuilt feature set without the XL bulk.
Comparison Table
| Product | Max turkey | Oil capacity | Power | Drain system | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Masterbuilt 3-in-1 10L XL (MB20012420) | 20 lb | 10 liters | 1,650 W | Drain valve with spout | Large holiday birds, year-round boils |
| Masterbuilt Butterball XL (23011114) | 20 lb | 10 liters | 1,650 W | Drain valve | Proven design, easy-clean porcelain pot |
| Cuisinart Rotisserie Fryer (CDF-500) | 14 lb | 5 liters | 1,800 W | Drain hose, removable container | Less oil, even browning, everyday frying |
| Masterbuilt Butterball Oil-Free (20100809) | 18 lb | None | 1,650 W | Drip pan | No-oil cooking with smoke flavor |
| Masterbuilt 8 Liter 3-in-1 (MB20010118) | 14 lb | 8 liters | 1,650 W | Drain valve | Small kitchens and smaller birds |
FAQ
Can you really use an electric turkey fryer indoors?
Yes, if the model is certified for indoor use, as the Masterbuilt Butterball and 3-in-1 fryers are. There is no open flame or propane, and a thermostat controls the oil. You still need a stable surface away from water, a fully thawed and dried turkey, and constant supervision. The oil-free roaster is the exception: it is electric but rated for outdoor use only.
How much oil does an electric turkey fryer need?
Plan on about 2.75 gallons for a 10-liter fryer, roughly 2 gallons for the 8-liter model, and much less for the Cuisinart rotisserie, whose container holds 5 liters. Fill only to the pot’s max line with the bird accounted for, since the turkey displaces oil. Peanut oil is the common choice for its high smoke point.
How long does an electric fryer take to cook a turkey?
Oil fryers run about 3.5 to 4 minutes per pound at 375°F, so a 16 lb turkey needs roughly an hour, plus up to 45 minutes of preheating for a large pot. The oil-free roaster is slower, at about 10 minutes per pound. Always confirm 165°F in the thickest part of the breast with an instant-read thermometer before serving.
Can you reuse the frying oil afterward?
Yes, usually a few times. Let the oil cool completely, drain it through the valve, and strain it through cheesecloth to remove crumbs, which turn used oil rancid and smoky. Store it sealed in a cool, dark place, and discard it once it darkens, foams or smells off.
Conclusion
For most households, the Masterbuilt 3-in-1 10 Liter XL is the electric turkey fryer to buy: it takes the biggest bird, drains safely, and earns its keep as a boiler and steamer all year. The Butterball XL is a close alternative with its easy-clean porcelain pot. Choose the Cuisinart rotisserie if your birds stay under 14 lb and you want to spend far less on oil, the 8-liter Masterbuilt if space is tight, and the oil-free roaster if skipping oil entirely matters more than a true deep-fried crust. Size the fryer to your turkey, respect the max fill line, and verify the temperature yourself.
FAQ
Can you really use an electric turkey fryer indoors?
How much oil does an electric turkey fryer need?
How long does an electric fryer take to cook a turkey?
Can you reuse the frying oil afterward?
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeA free business account with business pricing and bulk-buying tools for work, shop or home office.
Create a business accountAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!