Key takeaways
- Find the best roasting pan for turkey, prime rib, and holiday roasts. We compare five real roasting pans with racks by size, rack, oven limit, and surface.
A roasting pan decides more about a holiday meal than most cooks expect. It holds the bird, collects the drippings that become gravy, and sets the ceiling on how large a turkey can go in the oven. A pan that is too small leaves a bird cramped against the sides, while a weak rack lets the meat sit in its own fat instead of browning all around.
The five roasting pans below all come with a rack, cover the sizes most home ovens accept, and represent the main materials cooks actually buy: stainless steel, tri-ply stainless, nonstick steel, and enamel on steel. Match the exact model before ordering.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Table of Contents
- Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Rack
- All-Clad Specialty Stainless Steel Roaster
- Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16-Inch Roasting Pan
- Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack
- Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster
- How to Choose
- Frequently Asked Questions
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Rack
The Cuisinart Chef’s Classic is the roasting pan most cooks reach for first, and the listing explains why. It is uncoated stainless steel with a pure aluminum base sealed between the steel layers, so heat spreads across the bottom instead of concentrating in hot spots. The removable stainless rack lifts a turkey clear of the drippings, and the pan is induction compatible with an oven and broiler rating of 500 degrees Fahrenheit. For a cook who roasts a bird once or twice a year and wants the same pan for prime rib, ham, and a large tray of vegetables, this is the most versatile shape in the roundup.
Size is the first thing to check, because this pan measures differently depending on which figure a source quotes. The listing gives pan dimensions of 16.8 inches long, 12.8 inches wide, and 3.4 inches high, while the same listing measures 21.1 inches long with the handles and rack in place. Other roundups quote 20.7 by 12 by 4.9 inches, which reads like the pan with handles. Measure the oven before ordering and use the handle-inclusive figure. The depth of 3.4 inches is on the shallow side, so a very large bird can sit close to the rim and juices accumulate faster than in a deeper pan.
The rack is a flat stainless wire rack rather than a V-shaped rack. A flat rack holds the turkey level and makes it easy to slide vegetables underneath, where they spread in a single layer and cook in the drippings. The rack has its own handles, so the bird can be lifted out while the pan stays on the counter for gravy.
One conflict deserves attention before ordering. The Amazon listing shows the model as not discontinued, yet one roundup notes that Cuisinart’s own site lists this model as discontinued, which would mean Amazon stock is whatever remains. The pan carries a lifetime warranty and is dishwasher safe. Confirm that the listing names model 7117-16UR and that the rack is included, since Cuisinart sells a smaller 14-inch lasagna pan with a rack under a different model number, and a 15-inch nonstick version under yet another code.
Specs
- Material: Stainless steel with aluminum-encapsulated base
- Size: 16.8 x 12.8 x 3.4 inches (pan); 21.1 inches long with handles and rack
- Rack: Removable stainless steel flat rack
- Oven limit: 500 degrees Fahrenheit, oven and broiler safe
- Induction compatible: Yes
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
- Model: 7117-16UR
- UPC: 086279176349
- Warranty: Lifetime
All-Clad Specialty Stainless Steel Roaster
The All-Clad Specialty roaster is the premium pick in this roundup. The pan is heavy-gauge polished stainless steel, 16 inches long, 13 inches wide, and 5 inches deep, with a V-shaped nonstick rack that cradles a turkey and lifts it clear of the drippings. The listing states a capacity of 25 pounds, the largest stated capacity in this roundup, and the pan is oven and broiler safe to 600 degrees Fahrenheit, the highest oven limit here. For a cook who roasts large birds and wants the pan to survive high-heat browning and broiling, this is the strongest build.
The V-shaped rack is the feature that sets this pan apart from the flat-rack picks. A V-rack holds the bird in a cradle, so the breast and legs stay centered and the skin browns evenly on both sides. The rack is nonstick coated, which makes it easier to lift a heavy bird off without the skin tearing, and the V shape collects drippings in the center of the pan for basting and gravy. The listing states a separate oven limit for the rack of 375 degrees Fahrenheit, lower than the pan’s 600-degree limit, so the rack should not go under a broiler or into an oven set above that figure. A cook who broils the bird at the end of roasting should remove the rack or keep the temperature within the rack’s limit.
Two details in the listing need a careful read. The pan is not induction compatible, so cooks with an induction cooktop cannot use it for stovetop gravy. The listing also states that the pan is designed in Pennsylvania and made in China, and the nonstick coating on the rack is not named, so its exact composition is not stated. The pan is dishwasher safe, and the listing shows the model as not discontinued. Confirm the listing names model 11644910099 and the 16 by 13 by 5 inch size, since All-Clad sells a smaller 11 by 14 inch version and a large 13 by 16 inch version under different model numbers, and the smaller version holds a 15-pound bird rather than 25 pounds.
Specs
- Material: Stainless steel
- Size: 16 x 13 x 5 inches
- Rack: V-shaped nonstick rack
- Capacity: 25 pounds
- Oven limit: 600 degrees Fahrenheit (pan); 375 degrees Fahrenheit (rack)
- Induction compatible: No
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
- Model: 11644910099
- UPC: 011644910099
- Warranty: Not stated
Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16-Inch Roasting Pan
The Cuisinart MultiClad Pro is the upgrade pick for cooks who make gravy on the stovetop. Its tri-ply construction runs an aluminum core up the sidewalls, not just across the base, so the pan heats evenly when it sits across two burners for deglazing. The listing states a capacity for turkeys up to 18 pounds, the pan is induction compatible and oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, and the included stainless rack is a flat rack with handles. For a cook who wants one pan to roast the bird and then build the gravy in the same pan, the tri-ply walls are the reason to choose this model over the Chef’s Classic.
The difference between the two Cuisinart pans in this roundup is the construction. The Chef’s Classic has an aluminum base sealed into the bottom only, which spreads heat across the floor of the pan but leaves the sidewalls as single-layer steel. The MultiClad Pro bonds aluminum through the full height of the walls, so the sides heat at nearly the same rate as the base, and the pan responds faster when the burner setting changes. That matters for gravy, where the drippings need to simmer evenly rather than scorch in one corner. The pan measures 19.3 inches long, 12.1 inches wide, and 5.2 inches high, deeper than the Chef’s Classic, with more room for juices from a large bird.
The listing carries a lifetime warranty and states that the pan is dishwasher safe. One point to confirm at checkout is the seller: the listing shows offers shipped from and sold by Amazon.com, and also offers from a third-party seller, so the exact seller can vary between visits. Confirm that the listing names model MCPS117-16BRP1 and that the rack is included, since Cuisinart sells the same pan body without a rack in some bundles, and the model number is the anchor that separates this tri-ply roaster from the single-ply Chef’s Classic. The pan is heavier than the Chef’s Classic, which is the price of the tri-ply walls, so a fully loaded bird needs two hands and a clear path from the oven to the counter.
Specs
- Material: Tri-ply stainless steel with aluminum core
- Size: 19.3 x 12.1 x 5.2 inches
- Rack: Stainless steel flat rack
- Capacity: Turkeys up to 18 pounds
- Oven limit: 500 degrees Fahrenheit
- Induction compatible: Yes
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
- Model: MCPS117-16BRP1
- UPC: 086279198952
- Warranty: Limited lifetime
Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack
The Circulon is the nonstick pick in this roundup, and it is also the largest pan here by footprint. At 17 inches by 13 inches, it gives more surface than any of the stainless picks, and the listing rates it for turkeys up to 24 pounds, close to the All-Clad’s 25-pound figure. The pan is heavy-duty alloy steel with a nonstick coating, and the included U-shaped rack is chrome plated. For a cook who dislikes scrubbing baked-on drippings from stainless steel and wants the easiest cleanup in the roundup, the nonstick surface is the reason to choose this pan.
The U-shaped rack works differently from the flat racks and the V-rack in this roundup. A U-rack has raised ends and a lower center, so the bird rests in a shallow cradle while the handles at each end give a place to grip when lifting a heavy roast out of the pan. The rack is chrome plated rather than nonstick coated, a small distinction, since the pan itself is nonstick and the rack is the part that touches the bird most directly. The wide handles make the pan easier to carry when it holds a large bird plus vegetables.
The tradeoff for the nonstick surface is durability and heat. The pan is oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, the lowest oven limit in this roundup, so it cannot go under a broiler or into a very hot oven for browning. The nonstick coating also wears over time, and the most common complaint in owner comments is the coating peeling or flaking, often at the bottom corners where drippings bake on. Use non-metal utensils, avoid abrasive scrubbing, and expect the coating to age faster than a stainless pan. The pan carries a lifetime warranty and is dishwasher safe. Confirm the listing names the 17 by 13 inch size, since Circulon sells a larger 18 by 15 inch version under a different listing, and the larger version needs a wider oven.
Specs
- Material: Alloy steel with nonstick coating
- Size: 17 x 13 inches
- Rack: U-shaped chrome-plated rack
- Capacity: Turkeys up to 24 pounds
- Oven limit: 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Induction compatible: Not stated
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
- Model: 56539
- Weight: 3.2 pounds
- Warranty: Lifetime
Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster
The Granite Ware is the budget pick and the only roaster in this roundup with a lid. It is enamel on steel, 19 inches long in an oval shape, and the listing states it accommodates poultry or a roast up to 20 pounds. The lid doubles as a second roaster, so the set covers two dishes at once, and the included V rack lifts the bird above the drippings. For a cook who roasts a few times a year and wants a lid to keep the bird moist, this is the most practical shape in the roundup.
The enamel surface is the main difference from the stainless picks. Enamel on steel heats quickly and holds heat well, and the listing states the roaster resists heat up to 935 degrees Fahrenheit, a figure that other sources give as 932 degrees, so the listing figure is the one to follow. The enamel is free of PFOA, PTFE, and PFOS, and the pan is dishwasher safe. The maker warns against using the roaster on a glass cooktop, and the porcelain surface can chip if the pan is dropped or knocked against a hard surface. A chip does not reduce the effectiveness of the cookware, according to the maker, but it does expose the steel underneath, so handle the pan with care when it is empty.
The oval shape fits a turkey differently from a rectangular pan. An oval roaster cradles a bird in a shape that matches the bird, which leaves less empty space at the corners, and the lid sits low over the bird to trap moisture. The tradeoff is that the oval shape holds fewer vegetables around the bird than a rectangular pan of the same length, and the roaster stands about 8.5 inches tall with the lid on, so the rack must sit low enough to clear the lid. Confirm the listing names model 322523 and that the V rack is included, since Granite Ware sells this roaster in several sizes and the 19-inch version is the one rated for a 20-pound bird. An older listing for the same roaster under a different code showed no featured offers available in a crawl, so the exact listing matters more here than for the other picks.
Specs
- Material: Enamel on steel
- Size: 19 inches long, oval
- Rack: V rack included
- Capacity: Poultry or roast up to 20 pounds
- Heat resistance: Up to 935 degrees Fahrenheit
- Lid: Included, doubles as a second roaster
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
- Model: 322523
- UPC: 785403005653
- Warranty: 2 years
How to Choose
Begin with the oven, because a roasting pan that does not fit is useless no matter how well it is built. Measure the interior width of the oven and the distance between the rack positions, then compare those figures with the pan’s dimensions including the handles. A 30-inch wall oven typically lists an interior width near 25 inches, which leaves room for a 16-inch pan with handles, but a smaller oven or a compact range can be tight. Allow at least an inch of clearance on each side so air can move around the pan, and check the height with the lid on if the pan comes with one.
Next, match the pan size to the bird. A 16-inch rectangular pan suits turkeys up to about 20 pounds, while a 17-inch pan or a 19-inch oval roaster gives room for a larger bird plus vegetables. The listing’s stated capacity is the figure to follow, and it is usually given as a turkey weight, so a pan rated for 18 pounds should not be asked to hold a 22-pound bird. A pan that is too large is also a problem, since drippings spread thin across a wide floor and can burn before there is enough liquid for gravy.
Then decide on the material and the rack. Stainless steel browns well, handles high heat, and goes on the stovetop for gravy, while nonstick releases food easily and cleans faster but tops out at a lower oven temperature and wears over time. Enamel on steel is light, inexpensive, and comes with a lid, but it cannot go on a glass cooktop and the surface can chip. For the rack, a V-rack cradles the bird and keeps it centered, a flat rack holds vegetables underneath in a single layer, and a U-rack gives grip points for lifting. Whichever rack a pan has, confirm that it is included, since some sellers list the pan alone and the rack separately.
Finally, check the oven limit and the handles. The oven limit is the ceiling for the pan, and the rack often has a lower limit than the pan, so read both figures. Handles should be riveted and wide enough to grip with oven mitts, because a fully loaded roasting pan is heavy, and a handle that is too small or too close to the pan wall makes the lift harder. A lifetime warranty is a good sign, but it covers defects, not wear, so the coating on a nonstick pan and the enamel on a steel pan still age with use.
Frequently Asked Questions
What size roasting pan fits a turkey?
A 16-inch rectangular pan fits most turkeys up to about 20 pounds, which covers the birds most households buy. A 17-inch pan or a 19-inch oval roaster gives more room for a larger bird and for vegetables around it. Measure the oven first, including the handles, and follow the capacity the listing states rather than guessing from the pan length alone.
Do I need a rack in a roasting pan?
A rack lifts the bird above the drippings, so hot air reaches the underside and the skin browns all around instead of steaming in the juices. The rack also makes it easier to lift a heavy bird out of the pan and leaves the drippings in the pan for gravy. A pan without a rack can still roast a bird, but the bottom skin stays pale and the meat sits in fat.
Can I make gravy in a roasting pan on the stovetop?
A stainless steel or tri-ply roasting pan can go on the stovetop for gravy, as long as the listing states it is stovetop safe and, for induction cooktops, induction compatible. A nonstick pan should not go on a burner for gravy, since the coating is not made for direct flame or high burner heat, and an enamel roaster should not go on a glass cooktop. Check the listing before setting the pan on a burner.
Is a nonstick roasting pan or a stainless steel roasting pan better?
A stainless steel pan browns better, handles higher oven temperatures, and lasts longer, while a nonstick pan releases food easily and cleans faster. Stainless steel suits cooks who roast often and make gravy in the pan, while nonstick suits cooks who roast a few times a year and want the easiest cleanup. Neither surface is wrong, and the choice comes down to how often the pan is used and how much scrubbing the cook wants to do.
Conclusion
The best roasting pan is the one that fits the oven, holds the bird, and matches how the cook works. The Cuisinart Chef’s Classic covers most households with a straightforward stainless design and a rack, while the MultiClad Pro adds tri-ply walls for cooks who make gravy on the stovetop. The All-Clad roaster is the strongest build for large birds and high heat, the Circulon is the easiest cleanup for cooks who prefer nonstick, and the Granite Ware is the practical budget choice with a lid for cooks who roast a few times a year. Measure the oven, confirm the exact model and the rack, and choose the pan whose size and surface fit the meals ahead.
FAQ
What size roasting pan fits a turkey?
Do I need a rack in a roasting pan?
Can I make gravy in a roasting pan on the stovetop?
Is a nonstick roasting pan or a stainless steel roasting pan better?
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeA free business account with business pricing and bulk-buying tools for work, shop or home office.
Create a business accountAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!