Updated Nov 19, 2026· 8 min read

Key takeaways

  • Compare five cookie cutter sets, from a 101-piece plastic collection to stainless rounds, hearts, and western shapes, and pick the set for your baking.

A good cookie cutter turns a plain sheet of rolled dough into a tray that looks planned. The right set cuts clean edges, holds its shape under pressure, and survives years of washing without bending or rusting. The wrong set tears soft dough, flexes on stiff gingerbread, or leaves ragged edges that icing cannot hide.

This guide covers cutter sets only, not cookie presses or stamps, which shape dough in a different way. The five picks below span the main buying choices: one big plastic collection for variety, two stainless round sets for everyday baking, one heart set for gifts and holidays, and one small western set for themed parties. Match the set to the cookies you actually bake, and check the size range before ordering.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Quick Answer

For most home bakers, the Ateco 5357 plain round set is the best buy: eleven graduated stainless rounds that cover biscuits, sugar cookies, and tart bases. Bakers who want the most shapes should take the Wilton 101-piece plastic set, while the Ateco 5307 fluted set suits scones and jam tarts. The Fox Run heart set and the Ann Clark cowboy set are the picks for trays and gifts.

The 5 Best Cookie Cutters

The Wilton 101-piece set is the variety pick. One hundred and one plastic cutters fill a storage pail, including the full alphabet and numbers, animals, holiday shapes, and everyday geometric shapes. No metal set in this guide offers letters and numbers, so this is the only pick here that puts a name or an age on a tray of cookies.

The cutters are plastic, and the listing title says so. Plastic cuts best through well-chilled, firm dough, and the wide lip on each cutter gives fingers a comfortable pressing surface. The average cutter measures about 3.5 by 3.5 inches, and the cutters are about half an inch deep. Care instructions conflict: Wilton’s own care copy says to wash in warm soapy water and dry thoroughly by hand, while some retailer listings call the set dishwasher safe. Hand wash to keep the plastic from warping.

This pick suits a baker who decorates cookies all year, a family that bakes with kids, or anyone who wants one set that covers every holiday. What does not fit: a plastic edge does not cut stiff gingerbread as cleanly as a steel rim, so a baker who works mostly with firm dough should choose a stainless set instead.

Spec Detail
Material Plastic
Pieces 101
Shapes Alphabet, numbers, animals, holiday, geometric
Average size About 3.5 x 3.5 in
Depth About 0.5 in
Storage Pail included
Care Hand wash recommended

Check price on Amazon

Check price on Amazon

Check price on Amazon

Check price on Amazon

Check price on Amazon

Ateco 5307 Fluted Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece

The Ateco 5307 is the fluted round set. Eleven graduated stainless rounds nest in a storage tin, and the crimped edge is more than decoration: the flutes give a biscuit or scone more surface to climb on as it rises, and they hide the raggedness a plain cut leaves in soft, high-fat dough.

Retailers publish two different ranges for the largest cutter, 3/4 inch to 3 1/4 inch at several shops and 0.75 to 3.5 inch at others, so treat the top size as approximate. The set is stainless steel throughout, which holds a sharp edge and resists rust when dried after washing. The cutters suit biscuits, scones, jam tarts, and dumpling wrappers.

This pick suits a baker who bakes scones and biscuits often and wants a fluted edge for a finished look. What does not fit: every cutter here is round, so a baker who wants shaped cookies for holidays needs a second set with shapes.

Spec Detail
Material Stainless steel
Pieces 11
Edge Fluted
Size range 3/4 to 3 1/4 in (retailers conflict on largest)
Storage Tin included
Dishwasher safe Not stated

Ateco 5357 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece

The Ateco 5357 is the plain round set, and the best first buy for most home bakers. Eleven graduated stainless rounds run from 3/4 inch to 3-5/8 inches, according to the Amazon listing, and each cutter is 1.25 inches tall with a rolled top edge that protects fingers during cutting. The set nests in a storage tin, and the listing calls the cutters dishwasher-safe.

Rounds are what a baker actually cuts most often: plain sugar cookies, biscuits, scones, dumpling wrappers, tart bases, doughnuts, and English muffins. One note on size: Ateco’s own catalog publishes the range as .75 to 3.5 inches, which differs slightly from the listing figure, so treat the largest cutter as approximate.

This pick suits a home baker who wants one durable set for everyday baking, and a baker who is buying a first set. What does not fit: the set holds only rounds, so holiday shapes and letters need a separate set, and the shallowest cutters may feel short for very thick biscuits.

Spec Detail
Material Stainless steel
Pieces 11
Edge Plain
Size range 3/4 to 3-5/8 in (catalog says to 3.5 in)
Height 1.25 in
Storage Tin included
Dishwasher safe Yes (per listing)

The Fox Run heart set is the themed pick. Five graduated stainless hearts nest in a storage tin, and the set has been sold since 2003 under model number 3680. Hearts are the most useful single shape after rounds: they work for Valentine’s Day, weddings, anniversaries, and any tray that needs a romantic touch.

The listing does not publish the size of each heart, so treat the exact range as not stated and measure on arrival if a specific size matters. The stainless steel holds a clean edge and resists rust when dried after washing. The tin keeps the five cutters together in a drawer.

This pick suits a baker who decorates for Valentine’s Day or weddings, or anyone buying a gift for a baker. What does not fit: five hearts of one shape cannot carry a whole holiday tray, so a baker who needs variety should pair this set with a larger collection.

Spec Detail
Material Stainless steel
Pieces 5
Shape Heart
Size range Not stated
Model 3680
Storage Tin included

The Ann Clark cowboy set is the small themed pick. Three cutters, a cowboy hat, a boot, and an oval plaque, are made in the United States from certified food-safe steel under SKU A6-756. The set ships from Amazon and is sold by Ann Clark Cookie Cutters, the maker itself.

Three cutters cannot cover a whole baking year, but that is not the point: this set exists for western-themed birthdays, rodeos, and country parties, where a hat and a boot on a tray say the theme at a glance. The oval plaque takes a name in icing, which suits party favors.

This pick suits a baker planning a western party or buying a themed gift. What does not fit: a baker who wants everyday shapes should look at the round sets above, and the exact cutter sizes are not stated on the listing, so measure on arrival if size matters.

Spec Detail
Material Certified food-safe steel
Pieces 3
Shapes Cowboy hat, boot, oval plaque
Made in USA
Model A6-756
Size range Not stated

How to Choose

Begin with material. Stainless steel holds the sharpest edge, cuts stiff dough cleanly, and lasts for years when dried after washing. Plastic is lighter and safer for kids, and it is the only way to get letters and numbers in one set, but it cuts best through chilled, firm dough and cannot be sharpened.

Count the shapes next. A round set covers the most baking, because biscuits, scones, and sugar cookies are all round. A shape set earns its place only when a holiday or a theme calls for it. Check the size range, too: a set of graduated sizes beats a set of one size.

Look at depth and storage. A cutter about an inch deep handles thick biscuit dough, while a shallow cutter suits thin sugar cookies. A storage tin or pail keeps a set together in a drawer. Hand wash and dry steel cutters promptly to keep rust away, and keep plastic cutters out of high heat.

Who Should Skip It

Not every baker needs a cutter set. If you bake only drop cookies, bars, and sheet cakes, a cutter adds nothing to your baking, and the money is better spent on a pan or a mixing bowl.

Bakers who want pressed or stamped designs should skip this guide entirely, because a cookie press or a stamp shapes dough in a different way from a cutter. The same applies to a baker who already owns a full set of rounds and shapes: a second set that repeats the same shapes adds clutter, not cookies.

FAQ

Metal cuts more cleanly, especially through stiff dough, and lasts longer when dried after washing. Plastic is lighter, safer for kids, and the only way to get a full alphabet and numbers in one set. Most bakers end up owning one of each: steel rounds for everyday baking and plastic for shapes and letters.

Chill the dough until it is firm, and dust the cutter lightly with flour before each cut. Press straight down and lift straight up, without twisting, because twisting drags the edge and tears the shape. If dough still sticks, chill the cut shapes on the tray before baking.

Some listings say yes, and the Ateco 5357 listing calls its cutters dishwasher-safe. Hand washing and drying promptly is still the safer habit, because trapped water in a storage tin can mark steel over time. Plastic cutters should follow the maker’s care copy: warm soapy water and air drying.

Cutters between 3 and 3.5 inches across suit most decorated sugar cookies: large enough to hold a design, small enough to bake evenly. Smaller cutters suit party favors and cookie platters, while cutters above 4 inches bake large cookies that need longer in the oven and more icing.

Final Verdict

The right set follows the cookies you bake. Most home bakers should begin with the Ateco 5357 plain round set, because eleven stainless rounds cover the most baking. Add the Wilton 101-piece plastic set when shapes and letters matter, and add the Ateco 5307 fluted set when scones and jam tarts are on the menu. The Fox Run heart set and the Ann Clark cowboy set are the finishing picks for themed trays and gifts. Whichever set you choose, chill the dough and cut straight down.

A
admin@88
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.

FAQ

Are metal or plastic cookie cutters better?
Metal cuts more cleanly, especially through stiff dough, and lasts longer when dried after washing. Plastic is lighter, safer for kids, and the only way to get a full alphabet and numbers in one set. Most bakers end up owning one of each: steel rounds for everyday baking and plastic for shapes and letters.
How do I keep dough from sticking to cookie cutters?
Chill the dough until it is firm, and dust the cutter lightly with flour before each cut. Press straight down and lift straight up, without twisting, because twisting drags the edge and tears the shape. If dough still sticks, chill the cut shapes on the tray before baking.
Can I put stainless steel cookie cutters in the dishwasher?
Some listings say yes, and the Ateco 5357 listing calls its cutters dishwasher-safe. Hand washing and drying promptly is still the safer habit, because trapped water in a storage tin can mark steel over time. Plastic cutters should follow the maker’s care copy: warm soapy water and air drying.
What size cookie cutters work best for decorated sugar cookies?
Cutters between 3 and 3.5 inches across suit most decorated sugar cookies: large enough to hold a design, small enough to bake evenly. Smaller cutters suit party favors and cookie platters, while cutters above 4 inches bake large cookies that need longer in the oven and more icing.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
Best Cookie Cutters for Holiday Baking and PartiesCheck price on Amazon

More from Amazon

Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.

Give Prime

Send a Prime gift membership to someone who would use free shipping and Prime Video.

Gift Amazon Prime
Audible gift membership

Give audiobooks to someone who loves to listen. Plans and prices are set by Amazon.

Gift Audible
Amazon Prime

Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Start a Prime free trial
Audible

Audiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Try Audible free

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.